$1+ Billion Recovered

Temporary S-Curve of Bridge Dangerous for Drivers

Explore more
articles

SUMMARY
Forty-two crashes in two months time on a single temporary S-curve on San Francisco’s Bay Bridge has led Caltrans to make a steady stream of improvements directed at improving driver safety through providing adequate advanced warning But, in an interesting anomaly, many commuters aren’t up in arms about the dangerous curve. The Contra Costa Times polled 410 readers, 57 percent of whom blamed driver carelessness rather than road design for the crashes.The danger of the S-curve gained notoriety after a November crash in which a truck carrying pears overturned, plummeting 200 feet and killing the driver.

The S-curve, also known as the “Yerba Buena Island Detour,” is the most significant realignment of the Bay Bridge since it opened in 1936. It changes two key features drivers had become accustomed to before the design change: a straightaway and a 50 mph speed limit. The S-curve forces drivers to adopt new habits, including slowing down to 40 mph for cars or 35 mph for trucks and heeding the curved lane lines. But even more disconcerting is the S-curve’s error tolerance of only 10 mph. Moderate speeders accustomed to zipping across the bridge at 60 mph will find themselves in danger of exceeding the error tolerance built into the bridge design.

In the wake of the crash last fall, Caltrans has struggled to provide adequate warnings to encourage drivers to slow down and to advise them of the unexpected change in conditions. The transportation agency has posted extra speed limit signs, pulled out the flashing lights, installed reflective striping on the barrier rails, and even brought in radar signs to remind drivers of their speed.

These warning measures have been effective in helping to reduce the unacceptable level of collisions caused by contact with the bridge as well as contact between vehicles who suddenly and unexpectedly fail to appreciate the fact and maintain their lane position.

The changes to the Bay Bridge came too late for those who have been injured by the poorly marked conditions. But the high profile nature of these collisions and the bridge project itself – illustrates how Caltrans and its engineers and design professionals need to analyze other construction projects to identify these hazards before another life is taken.

The people of California rely on Caltrans to provide safe roadways. Their taxes pay for the inspection or maintenance of the roadway system. Caltrans has adopted guidelines and mandates for design and signage. They need to follow their own advice and mandates for safety so that families crossing the Bay Bridge, and traveling on other highways in California make it home safely.

These considerations need to be undertaken by Caltrans before someone gets harmed. With their years of experience, and knowledge of driver behavior Caltrans has to adapt its design and signing projects to minimize the risk of injury. Responding after someone is harmed or killed is too little, too late.


Contact Our San Francisco Truck Accident Attorneys

If you have any questions, or if you have been involved in a California truck accident,
contact The Dolan Law Firm for a free consultation, and discover how San Francisco truck accident lawyers achieved our successful track record and reputation for excellence.

get the latest news

Frequently Asked Questions

Individual, attentive legal representation by highly experienced crash and accident attorneys with an outstanding record of success;
Substantial investigative, financial and technological resources that no individual attorney or small law firm can provide.

Individual, attentive legal representation by highly experienced crash and accident attorneys with an outstanding record of success;
Substantial investigative, financial and technological resources that no individual attorney or small law firm can provide.

Individual, attentive legal representation by highly experienced crash and accident attorneys with an outstanding record of success;
Substantial investigative, financial and technological resources that no individual attorney or small law firm can provide.

Individual, attentive legal representation by highly experienced crash and accident attorneys with an outstanding record of success;
Substantial investigative, financial and technological resources that no individual attorney or small law firm can provide.

SUMMARY

get the latest news

How it works

Intake meeting with our case managers

Evidence gathering with our legal teams

Pre-litigation settlement efforts

Litigation

Resolution or trial/arbitration

Get started
Scroll to Top